Earlier the king had had compassion on him (Matthew 18:27), but now he angrily hands the man over to the torturers (which implies a pagan setting) until he has paid his debt. Since this is impossible, it is a punishment without end. When the officer’s debt was forgiven, it was not for his great promises or accomplishments. Rather, it was his pleading and the king’s mercy that brought that result. The forgiveness was received unconditionally, but this forgiveness could not be preserved unconditionally, so the reckoning has two phases, a first (Matthew 18:24–27), followed by a second (Matthew 18:32–34), and which corresponds to the reality in the kingdom: forgiveness in both the present and in the future. To answer this question, we must keep in mind the context of Matthew 18:23, about the servants who managed the king’s finances or collected taxes for him, so there is a clear link between the amount that the slave could not pay to his king and the sum that his colleague apparently owes him. Having failed to collect the outstanding taxes when they were due, he could not pay back what belonged to the king. The reason for the loan was to collect the overdue payments in order to use them in due course to pay the master back. Yet the king’s grace meant that the slave no longer had to trace the unpaid money and pay it to the king. The king did not insist that the slave collect what belonged to the king. Although he had not worried before about the king’s money, he now insists on his own advantage, so the king can call him to order. Since this servant wants to enrich himself by collecting payments that are no longer due, he brings up the cancelled debt again. And because of how he does that, the king has no mercy. This parable does not mean that sins, once forgiven, can again be charged against a man, as this issue is not under consideration.
Earlier the king had had compassion on him (Matthew 18:27), but now he is angry and hands the man over to the torturers (which implies a pagan setting) until he has paid his debt. Since this is impossible, it effectively constitutes a punishment without end. When the officer’s debt was forgiven, it was not because he had made great promises or because he had accomplished something. Rather, it was his pleading and the king’s mercy that produced that result. The forgiveness was then received unconditionally, but this forgiveness could not be preserved unconditionally. As such we see that the reckoning has two phases, a first (Matthew 18:24–27) which is followed by a second (Matthew 18:32–34), and which corresponds to the reality in the kingdom of God: that there is forgiveness in both the present and in the future.1
In answering this question, we must also keep in mind Matthew 18:23, which provides important context for this parable, for it concerned servants who managed the king’s finances or collected taxes for him. Therefore, there is an inherent connection between the amount that the slave could not pay to his king and the sum that his colleague apparently owes him. He has neglected to collect the outstanding taxes when they were due. It is for this reason that he could not pay back that which properly belonged to the king. The very reason for the loan was to collect the overdue payments in order to use them in due course to pay the master back. Yet when the king granted him grace it meant that the slave no longer had to trace the unpaid money and pay it to the king. The king does not insist that the slave collect that which properly belongs to him.
Although he had not earlier worried about the money of the king, he now mercilessly insists on his own honour and advantage. This is why the king can now call him to order. Now that he wants to enrich himself by collecting payments that are no longer due, he brings up the canceled debt again. And because of the way he does that, the king has no mercy whatsoever this time.2
One may not conclude from this parable that sins, once forgiven, can somehow again be charged against a man, as this issue is not under consideration.3
33 And should not you have had mercy on your fellow servant, as I had mercy on you?’